Granville Community Calendar

BZBA Minutes 10/23/1997

BOARD OF ZONING AND BUILDING APPEALS

October 23, 1997

Minutes

Present: Ashlin Caravana, Bob Essman, Lon Herman, Greg Sharkey,

Eric Stewart

Members Absent:

Also Present: Reza Reyazi, Village Planner

Visitors: Scott Rawden (Sentinel),Bob Seith, Joyce Munro, Carl

Frazier, Bill Acklin; Steve Miller, John Burris

Minutes:

PRESENTED;

APPROVED.

July 24: MR. SHARKEY MOVED TO APPROVE MINUTES AS

MS. CARAVANA SECONDED, AND MINUTES WERE UNANIMOUSLY

Citizens Comments: None

Public Hearing:

1st Presbyterian Church, 110 West Broadway

Bill Acklin introduced the plans for expansion of the

church, to be constructed between the existing church and the

Christian Education Building. Tonight they are seeking variances

for parking, lot coverage, and setbacks.

GPC has already approved Phase I, although, Mr. Reyazi

stated, GPC was concerned about historic preservation of the

original church and the massing of the new building. John Reagan

was hired as architectural consultant and he offered advice,

which was used to modify the plans, i. e.,maintaining the four

corners of the church and lessening the square footage and

massing of the plans, and careful blending of new and old structures.

GPC reviewed the height issue and said that relative to

existing buildings, they decided the height would be reasonable.

Regarding Setbacks, the Village Manager is investigating

whether any utilities would be affected by building in the ROW,

and it is within powers of Village Council to grant permission.

Mr. Acklin showed the architectural drawings and explained

that the chimney already encroaches into the ROW by 1 foot on the CE Building. They are asking that the portico stick out into the ROW by a few feet.

The alley is a Public Square, owned by the Village and established to meet the public need. Village Council needs to take action on building in the alley.

Other churches are very close to the streets. and other churches have done renovations.

The height of the structure is necessary to contain the

The parking area is short about 25 spaces. Mr. Acklin said

they do not have a big problem on Sunday mornings, and all

churches have insufficient on-site parking. There appears to be

no solution to this issue.

Mr. Acklin described the planned uses for the addition,

which will house areas for all users of the growing church. The

child-care business will not take place in the new addition. Mr.

Herman asked whether efforts were made to avoid the necessity of

variances, and Mr. Acklin said there is nothing that can be done

about the parking, and the basement is not useable space. One

alternative would be to purchase additional homes and tear them

down, which is unacceptable. Mr. Burris added that 4 parking

spaces would be destroyed but 3 would be added. The elevator is

a prime concern, and if they put it in the old building, it would

remove one stained-glass window and reduce seating and would not

serve the CE building. Mr. Stewart asked about bridging the

alley and Mr. Acklin said it was considered but that would not

provide enough space, would not look very good, and would not

house an elevator.

Lot Coverage is 80%and the addition will increase by 3. 5%,

and other churches have extensive lot coverage. Mr. Hardin has

lot coverage for the Methodist church. Ms. Caravana would like

to see footprints for the other churches from the outside to the

sidewalks.

Bob Seith, neighbor to the west, has enormous problems with

the plans and with using the alley to accomplish goals. The

building will cut off light and access to his house. One problem

is that they do not own the property. There might be problems

with fire-engine access on Sunday mornings. He spoke to the

specific variance requests: parking is pretty tight on Sunday

mornings. Tkere are engineering problems with lot coverage;

during downpours the storm sewers overflow and the more asphalt

there is, the more runoff you get. Mr. Miller added that the

Service Director will study this issue carefully. Setback is in

question on Main Street only, although the Locust Street side is

very tight, and the addition will fill the available space.

BZBA members discussed how the plans could meet with Mr.

Seith' s objections (Criteria E, Health, Safety, and General

Welfare of neighbors),and Mr. Acklin reminded them that sunlight

is not an issue legally. But members are trying to recognize issues on both sides.

Ms. Caravana thought that the plans would not add to the parking problems downtown. She felt that the new building facade

would be more attractive to Mr. Seith' s view.

Members were concerned about other churches encroaching into

-organ -pipesv': Tt'bsa-s-to<w'«as p' ossible »ands""til<t->g"et-sa'nwarrantee",=-·»v·'"·=

able roof.

··',<,·R-eW·y- and"w,anted,>more ·i·nformation*.A ·,N·-ovember -4-o-'n-site ·

vation was agreed upon preparatory to a November 6 vote.

Ms CARAVANA TO CLOSE THE PUBLIC HEARING UNTIL THE 6TH OF

NOVEMBER. IT WAS SECONDED AND UNANIMOUSLY APPROVED.

Work Session: Review of "Rules and Regulations"

MS. CARAVANA MOVED TO ADOPT THE RULES AND REGULATIONS AS

AMENDED; MR. SHARKEY SECONDED, AND MOTION WAS UNANIMOUSLY

APPROVED.

Adjournment: 9: 00 p.m.

Next Meetings: November 4, 4 p.m.,on-site at Church. November

6, vote on Church application. (Betty will be absent.)

November 20, regular meeting.

Employee Payroll / Compensation

The Village has thirty-six (36) full-time employees, 16 regular part-time employees and seaonal employees. Village Personnel Policy

Go to My Pay Stub and login.