GRANVILLE PLANNING COMMISSION
Members Present: Barb Lucier, Keith Myers, Mark Parris, Richard Salvage, Carl Wilkenfeld
Members Absent: Jack Burriss
Also Present: Seth Dorman, Village Planner
Visitors Present: Andrew Furr, Michael J. Eisenman, Paul Jakob, Mike Frazier, Leta Ross, Jim and
The Chair,Keith Myers,swore in all those who planned to speak.
Minutes of June 11,2001:
Page 3, halfway down, M" r. Salvage said the school wants to increase security after dropo- ff
Page 4, halfway down,T "here was discussionD..a.n Rogers said that this has been in his
Page 4, 2 lines down from that one, M" r. Burriss said the structure
Page 4,Mr. Parris paragraph,B Z "B..A. granted variances for the previous application, and
Page 4, 9 lines from bottom, H"e thought the design was too big for a saltbox style roof."
Page 5, first paragraph, U..42)a small roof over the garage doors may be worthwhile and
should be ofmetalD..e.le"te number 4( ). 6 ).tr.a.d(itional detailing 7)architectural eaves and
brackets will be added. "
MR. SALVAGE MOVED TO APPROVE THE MINUTES AS AMENDED. MR. WILKENFELD
SECONDED, AND THE MOTION WAS UNANIMOUSLY APPROVED.
Denison University. Thresher Street L-ot Split
Mr. Dorman said the applicant wants to convey 0.20 acres to 220 Thresher Street from land
owned by Denison because the Jung's garage rests on Denison property. No concerns were noted at the
MR. WILKENFELD MOVED TO APPROVE APPLICATION # 01-072 AS PRESENTED. MR.
PARRISS SECONDED,AND THE MOTION WAS UNANIMOUSLY APPROVED.
Leta Ross.470 South Main -Brick Patio
Mr. Dorman stated the applicant wants to install a brick patio with landscaping around
Knuckleheads on the east side. There will be outdoor seating on the patio. GPC members felt this would
be an improvement over what is there now.
MR. WILKENFELD MOVED TO APPROVE APPLICATION # 01-074 AS PRESENTED. MR.
SALVAGE SECONDED,AND THE MOTION WAS UNANIMOUSLY APPROVED.
Granville Planning Commission,6/25/ 01
Paul Jakob,115 West College Street -Renovations
Mr.Dorman explained that the applicant wishes to renovate the house with a new patio,staircase
connecting living level to the patio,replacement windows and door,and to screen the air conditioner. Mr.
Jakob explained that the house slopes down and has no rear exit except through the basement. A sun
porch added fifty years ago is deteriorating and the plans will make the room usable and improve
appearance. GPC members thought the plans were very well done.
MR. SALVAGE MOVED TO APPROVE APPLICATION0 #1-076 AS PRESENTED. MR. PARRIS
SECONDED,AND THE MOTION WAS UNANIMOUSLY APPROVED.
Jim Dumbmild,107 North Prospect StreetG -arage Door
Mr.Dorman showed pictures ofthe location,behind the barbershop,and Mr. Dumbauld added
that he wishes to add a door to the garage for protection. There is a tall picket fence on the sides. It is to
be a Wayne DaltonW "ayneMark 8000w" hite metal door without windows.
MR..WILKENFELD MOVED TO APPROVE APPLICATION0 #1-077 AS PRESENTED.
MR.SALVAGE SECONDED,AND THE MOTION WAS UNANIMOUSLY APPROVED.
Michael Eisenman,117 East Elm StreetS -ign
The application is for a black and white,3.25 square foot sign on the existing signpost for the
former tenant's sign. Mr. Myers thought entarging the word P"odiatrista"nd his name and making the
telephone number smaller could improve the design. Mr. Wilkenfeld suggested omitting the area code,
and Mr. Salvage suggested a border around the sign. Dr. Eisenman said it would be luster board,a shiny
material with black letters applied. It will not be painted.
MR. SALVAGE MOVED TO APPROVE APPLICATION0 #1-080,SUBJECT TO THE FOLLOWING:
1)THAT THE APPLICANT HAVE THE OPTION TO PUT A BLACK BORDER AROUND THE
SIGN;AND ( 2)THAT THE TEXT IS MODIFIED SUCH THAT"PODIATRIST"IS BOLD OR A
LARGER FONT SIZE TO SET IT OFF,AND THAT THE PHONE NUMBER MATCH THE REST OF
THE TEXT (Not bold and smaller).MR. WILKENFEND SECONDED,AND THE MOTION WAS
Mr. Lucier reminded the group that Mr. Pinkerton had at one time applied for a change ofuse for a
beauty shop and was approved for it. Ifthis were still in effect,it would require a change ofuse back to
what it had been previously. Mr. Salvage thought that technically,Dr. Raker o(wner)should make the
application to return the building to the former use.
CertifiedOil Company,433 SouthMain StreetR -enovation
Following up on several work sessions,Andy Furr presented formal plans for the razing and
renovations,taking into account all suggestions by GPC. Mr. Furr has been talking to IGA owners about
traffic patterns but has not come to final decision.
Mr. Furr explained the facade with dormers for the plan,which was redrawn according to
recommendations ofMr. Burriss. He also explained the lighting plan in detail,which met with praise
from GPC. If and when the Village adds streetlights in the area,two of Certified's pole lights closest to
South Main Street could be eliminated,but Mr. Furr wants to keep the ground light for the sign.
Mr. Myers had several suggestions on the landscaping plan,to which Mr. Furr agreed. The plan 2
Granville Planning Commission,6/25/01
has not yet gone to the Tree and Landscape Committee. He recommended eliminating decorative and boulders. Consensus grass agreed with Mr. Myers, resulting in the following motion:
MR. SALVAGE MOVED TO APPROVE APPLICATION # 01-079,SUBJECT TO THE FOLLOWING:
1)IN THE FRONT LANDSCAPING ISLAND: A)THE DENSE YEWS WILL BE 30"ON CENTER
AND A MINIMUM HEIGHT OF 24"AT INSTALLATION;B)IN THE AREA OF THE SIGN,WE
WILL USE ONLY TAXUS HEDGE WITH A DOUBLE-STAGGERED ROW;C)BETWEEN THE
MONUMENT SIGN AND THE FRONT OF THE LANDSCAPE ISLAND USE THE MEIDILAND
ROSES AND WE WILL ELIMINATE THE BOULDERS AND BARBERRY;D)WE WILL REDUCE
THE LARGE TREES FROM 4 TO 3. ( 2)IN THE AREA OF THE PARKING STALLS,WE WILL
SCREEN AROUND THE PARKING STALLS WITH ANY SPECIES OF VIBURNUM,36"ON
CENTER WITH A 30"MINIMUM HEIGHT AT INSTALLATION. 3()LANDSCAPING ALONG
THE EAST PROPERTY LINE WILL CONSIST SOLELY OF NORWAY SPRUCE - ON THE SOUTH
SIDE OF THE BUILDING THERE WILL BE 11 OF THESE TREES 8-15' ONCENTER AND ON
THE NORTH SIDE OF THE BUILDING THERE WILL BE 6 OF THESE TREES 8-15' ON CENTER.
4)THERE WILL BE 2 LARGE CANOPY TYPE TREES,ONE ON EITHER SIDE OF THE ACCESS
DRIVE TO THE DUMPSTER. 5 ()ON THE DORMERS,ON THE ROOF,REMOVE THE PIECE OF
BLOCK TRIM ON EITHER SIDE OF THE DORMERS. ( 6)APPROVE THE USE OF THE LOT
LIGHT FIXTURE"ALAIRE"BY SPAULDING LIGHT WITH THE FIXTURE AND POLE TO BE
BLACK. ( 7)ALIGN,THE LIGHT POLE BY THE MOMUMENT SIGN WITH THE SIGN. ( 8)THE
APPLICANT HAS AGREED TO ELIMINATE THE TWO POLE LIGHTS CLOSEST TO SOUTH
MAIN STREET IF THE VILLAGE PUTS IN STREET LIGHTS SUFFICIENT TO PROVIDE
ADEQUATE ENTRANCE LIGHTING.
MR. WILKENFELD SECONDED,AND THE MOTION WAS UNANIMOUSLY APPROVED.
Mr. Dorman is to tell BZBA that we are strongly in favor of this plan.
Finding of Fact:
MR. WILKENFELD MOVED TO APPROVE THE FINDINGS OF FACT FOR A THROUGH F
UNDER NEW BUSINESS, AND WE FIND THEM CONSISTENT WITH RELEVANT SECTIONS
OF THE VILLAGE PLANNER'S MEMO OF JUNE 22, 2001. MR. PARRIS SECONDED, AND
THE MOTION WAS UNANIMOUSLY APPROVED.
Adjournment: 8:35 p.m.
Next Meetings:July 9 and July 23
GRANVILLE PLANNING COMMISSION