GRANVILLE PLANNING COMMISSION
November 23, 2009
Members Present: Jack Burriss, Jeremy Johnson, Councilmember O’Keefe (non-voting), Tim Ryan (Chair).
Members Absent: Tom Mitchell
Staff Present: Village Planner, Alison Terry
Visitors Present: Shawn Bogan
No one appeared to speak under Citizen’s Comments.
123 South Prospect Street– Jeanetta Pyle - Application #09-143 REVISED
Village Residential District (VRD) – Architectural Review Overlay District (AROD)
The request is for architectural review and approval of a slate roof replaced with
dimensional asphaltic shingles in a slate color.
Swearing in of Witnesses – Mr. Ryan swore in Shawn Bogan.
Discussion regarding Application #09-143:
Shawn Bogan, roofer, stated that he was representing the homeowner, Jeanetta Pyle, because she was unable to attend the Planning Commission meeting. Mr. Bogan indicated that he would be the roofer. He provided a sample of the exact shingle to be used. Mr. Burriss questioned how the ridge detail would be handled. Mr. Bogan indicated that the ridge detail and finials would be the same as the existing details and color. Mr. Johnson asked if the eaves would be vented. Mr. Bogan indicated that the vents would be installed in the soffits. Vents will also be vented in the ridges. The vents would be two-inch round and painted to match the trim. Mr. Burriss asked if the ridge lines would be higher. Mr. Bogan indicated that the ridges would be perhaps one half inch higher. There will be no changes to the gutters or down spouting.
The Planning Commission reviewed the Standards and Criteria pertaining to Application #09-143:
a) Is stylistically compatible with other new, renovated and old structures in the Village District. Other slate roofs have been permitted to be replaced in this district. The Planning Commission concluded yes.
b) Contributes to the improvement and upgrading of the historical character of the Village District. As the applicant would be maintaining the same ridge and finial details and using materials that would maintain the look of slate, the applicant would be maintaining the historical character of the district. The Planning Commission concluded yes.
c) Contributes to the continuing vitality of the District. By contributing to the vitality of a structure in the district, it maintains the entire district. The Planning Commission concluded yes.
d) Protects and enhances examples of the physical surroundings in which past generations lived. The improvements are a reproduction of the original material and detail, which protects and enhances the physical surroundings. The Planning Commission concluded yes.
Mr. Burriss made a motion to approve amended Application #09-143 as submitted.
Seconded by Mr. Johnson.
Roll Call Vote: Burriss, Johnson, Ryan. Motion carried 3-0.
Application #09-143 is approved as submitted.
Finding of Fact Approvals:
Application #09-143: Jeanetta Pyle
Approve Findings of Fact and Associated Standards and Criteria.
The Planning Commission found the request to be consistent with The Granville Codified Ordinances Chapter 1159, Village District, and Chapter 1161, Architectural Review Overlay District, hereby gives their recommendation of approval for Application #09-143.
Mr. Burriss moved to approve the Findings of Fact for Application #09-143. Seconded by Mr. Johnson.
Roll Call Vote: Johnson, Burriss, Ryan. Motion carried 3-0.
Approval of Absent Planning Commission Member:
Mr. Burriss made a motion to excuse Tom Mitchell from the November 23, 2009 Planning Commission meeting. Seconded by Mr. Johnson. Motion carried 3-0.
Approval of the Minutes:
Mr. Johnson made a motion to approve the minutes for the November 9, 2009 Planning Commission meeting as presented. Seconded by Mr. Burriss. Motion carried 3-0.
Adjournment: 7:20 PM
Mr. Burriss moved to adjourn the Planning Commission meeting, seconded by Mr. Johnson. Motion carried 3-0.
December 14, 2009
January 11, 2010